Guess the grade--NGC 1936 Buffalo Nickel

Please guess the grade of this Buffalo Nickel. I am guessing it will take 2 pages to get the right answer. Somebody impress me please!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

MS-66

What a GREAT looking Buffalo Nickel! Excellent strike. At first I thought it might be a Proof but I don't think it is. Then again it could be a proof - one of the early '36 Proofs before the Mint changed to the Brilliant Proof version.

 

66 66 66 - a perfect 66

 

This coin is hot! At first glance I saying to myself 65+, while looking closer for any problems with this coin frankly I haven't seen any.. The reverse toning pattern is only going to get better over the coming years. WOW!

This is a hot package, the rim on this coin looks exceptional, as do the objects and fields of each side. Very Mint! MS67.

Thanks for sharing the pictures.

Allen

 

I'm going to say MS-67.

 

wow!! what a gorgeous coin!!!! i have a hard time just giving a coin an ms65 grade but this is at least an ms66. great strike..so incredibly clean and lustrous. i would be honored to have this one in my collection...thank you so much for sharing!!!
my very best wishes...steve

 

I'm going with MS-67. And I agree with everyone else - this is one of the nicest buff's I've ever seen.

/edit to add -

I just saw in the title that it's graded by NGC, so I'm going to add the * designation to my grade and say their grade for it is MS-67*

 

Out of ignorance, PR67 type 1

 

I think you might have something PR68.

 

I'd give it a 68 at least, I see no problems with it or on it. PR? Rims are really sharp. A really sweet coin!

 

PF-66 is my guess. satin finish. The edges look sharp, and if it's not a proof, it is the cleanest business strike I have ever seen!!

 

RLM is too good. Congratulations, you nailed it.

 

DAng, you posted the answer before I got to respond. (I would've been off though, my guess would've been MS-67. Still, beautiful coin, that's a keeper!!! :thumb

Phoenix

 

And we did it in 1 page.