Guess the grade #88

1958-D PCGS slabbed

I will try to get the last 6 scored tomorrow.

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms_68

 

66. The mark smack in the middle of the reverse keeps it from getting higher.

 

65 with that hit smack dab in the middle of the reverse....but luster rules and they ignored that.

 

I say MS-66. No way could this be a 67 because of that mark on the reverse. I would be surprised if this got 67. If it did, then I have no idea why; luster?

 

65, the scratch in the middle and above the O in one detract from a higher grade in my opinion.

 

Interesting coin to grade.

Obverse 67+.
Reverse 66 at best. The ding in the middle appears to be a strikethrough to my eye.

I said obverse (luster!) took the day, and graded 67.

 

Same as other I went 66 because of the hit on the Rev.

 

65+1

 

This poll and http://www.cointalk.com/t132971/ will be closing tomorrow.

 

You pretty much nailed this one. It is a 66 even though a little weak at the O in ONE.

 

OK! Here is number 50. By my rules, Larry wins, but you can interpret as you please. Duke comes in second if you are technical, but I would call it a tie with baha,

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.
ldhair 0.412 18
Duke Kavanaugh 0.478 48
bahabully 0.479 50
Leadfoot 0.500 48
ddoomm1 0.514 39
mark_h 0.553 49
BadThad 0.563 50
swhuck 0.585 43
jallengomez 0.708 26
Anarchos 0.765 18

 

I'll take second any day with all these guys.
But I think with only 18 guess's that it's really a tie with Bahabully and me which would keep me at second either way

Thanks for holding this RLM.
I think I got better every time you posted them. And the others I think did too.

 

It's all fun! Thanks for doing this bro.

....I still think a correction factor should be considered to reward more guessing.....but it's still cool.

Congrats Larry! Nice score! :thumb:

 

Thanks RLM! These have become some of my favorite threads.

 

Congrats Larry!!

 

I'll take .001 proximity to Duke any day ! Good stuff RLM !,, as has been said already,, thank you for putting this show on the road.
Keep em' coming... I say best 2 out of three is the winner !

 

I'll concede that Duke and bahabully are the real winners here. You guys are really good at this.
I'll take 10th place, that sounds fair. Thanks RLM for all the hard work.

 

4th place? Unacceptable!

Thanks for putting this together, RLM.

 

lol No you won.
There were rules set and you beat us. I'm just glad to learn and be that close. Besides there's more being posted
Thank you again RLM