#2 1912-D PCGS slabbed NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted This one will be a minor bit different. Here are 3 1912-D's. The first 2 are graded by PCGS and they will count in the cumulative scores. Plus a third graded by ICG that will not count, but I would appreciate your grading / opinions. (Please score the ICG with your honest grade, not what you think ICG gave it.) There is at least one of these I think is misgraded, so please add all the comment you can.
thinking Im a bit conservative when I voted an MS-60 (just doesnt seem like anything that "good", not to dis the coin , but no luster a weak observe)
Now that's one edited 1912-D! You suck award here....yes, you suck. My 1912-D is a crappy F-12 because I cannot find a sharp one of these in RB raw. This is a tough, tough coin! I hope PCGS didn't brown it, I'd call it RB. Did I tell you that you suck? LOL :devil:
This one, http://www.cointalk.com/t126398/, and http://www.cointalk.com/t126400/ will be ending tomorrow.
This coin I really do not understand the grade. In hand this is a nice coin - probably nicer than the 64 in #63. My pictures did not catch it well, but this coin has plenty of luster. It has a couple of marks, but to me has much more eye appeal than #63. To me, if this is not a 63, it is a 64. I do not understand the 62 PCGS gave it.
Well, most are still beatingthe crap out of last round's scores. Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses. bahabully 0.333 26 ldhair 0.333 10 ddoomm1 0.389 19 BadThad 0.417 26 mark_h 0.435 25 Duke Kavanaugh 0.458 26 Leadfoot 0.500 24 swhuck 0.600 22 Anarchos 0.800 16 tmoneyeagles 0.800 16
