Guess the Grade #604

1958-D PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I say MS-66.

 

67

 

Thinking 66 .

 

Thinking 66 too

 

6

 

Blazer, I want to go with 67 and I do think it is...but I'm going conservative this round.

 

I marked 67 as there was no 66+ noted.
66+is what I would graded it!
Nice one rLm!!

 

Hate to say this, but if it was NGC I think I would have went 67.

 

Don't hate to say it, say it because it's true. NGC is definitely more lenient (and unpredictable) from 66-68 than PCGS. Over the many years of this contest I know I've missed more NGC grades than PCGS.

 

I started to guess this one a 67. Great looking coin.

 

I think a lot of us wanted to go 67 on this coin , and if it was NGC I would have .

 

I agree @Ngc but Pcgs ya have hope who in a giving mood.

 

This poll and http://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-603-correct.241774/ will be closing tonight.

 

Now this coin has luster to spare. The strike may not be perfect, but it is close. Just a couple small nicks that I don't think are that significant. I could not argue much if they had given this a 67, but I think I would have gone 66+. Somehow PCGS only managed a 66 and I am pretty sure this was graded when the + was available.

 

BadThad moved up a spot but that was the only change this round.

Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.
1. ldhair 0.139 38
2. rzage 0.261 48
3. mark_h 0.273 46
4. petro89 0.275 42
5. BadThad 0.318 46
6. jallengomez 0.345 30
7. non_cents 0.444 28
8. ReaperRuler 0.574 49
9. jester3681 0.604 50
10. Johntomk 0.640 26

 

I wanted to go 67 on this one , but with such a big jump in price from 66 to 67 especially a PCGS 67 , I figured they'd be very conservative on it .

 

Based on your pics - I'm in the 67 camp, that luster is crazy. It is a slightly weak strike so I see why they held it back.

 

I maybe wrong @ Pcgs
was not + a extra fee, Secure Option ???

 

I really thought this would get a plus . PCGS is getting stingy again .