Guess the Grade #575 NEW

1919-S NGC slabbed

The line above LIBERTY is my mistake ON THE SLAB and not on the coin.

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

63

 

Nice one. I think a 64, 65 if more luster. So another swag at a NGC coin.

 

I went 64 , but I could see this as a 65 .

 

This poll and http://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-576-new.237374/ will be closing tonight.

For the next few weeks, only Wednesday,s GTG will be run.

 

Voted too quick did not disclaimer about scratch.

 

This coin has a very nice strike. Not just nice for San Francisco, but nice period. There are only a couple very tiny nicks, but there are a couple small spots that I would not consider particularly distracting. The reverse has pretty good luster, but the obverse luster is a bit weak. NGC called all of this a 64 and I agree. BTW, it is RB.

 

One right and one off by one , starting to revert to old habits .

 

FWIW, that 27-S was a tough one and I still think you (and I) were right and NGC wrong.