Guess the Grade #569

1935- PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Wow would look great in my collection, however again Bag marks are going to lower the grade slightly. Can not wait to see the actual grades

 

If in an NGC holder I would have went 67. This one is very nice.

 

66

 

This poll and http://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-570.236861/ will be closing tonight.

 

Great luster and just a few very minor ticks away from a PCGS 67 . 66+ but a 67 wouldn't surprise me . Then again maybe I should check Heritage .

 

AU58.

 

Why AU - 58 ?

 

everyone picked 66 , where's Thad ? He might go 67 . Car 54 where are you ?

 

I have never seen you so united on a grade. Funny as I am not sure I agree. It has a dead solid strike, blooming luster, and I can just barely catch a single nick. I have seen coins with less luster AND a much poorer strike get a 67, why not here? I am not sure what PCGS saw, but they only gave it a 66. Not sure they were give +'s when this was graded, but at the least, I believe this deserved a 66+, However, I still think a 67 would have been better.

 

I came so close to going 67 on this one , even after looking at Heritage it looked close to some of the lower end 67s , if it was NGC this would have made 67 easy .