Tough coin, I think I see some luster but slightly impaired in spots. I hope they didn't get rough on it.
Another one that I don't get. Good solid strike and nearly mark free (I find one). Yes, there are a couple blotches on the coin, but none are really that disturbing or eye catching. The luster on the obverse is good, but the reverse almost looks like it has a haze on it, but the luster still comes out. IMO there is just too much going for this coin not to be a 65. However, PCGS only saw it as a 64.
Doesn't make sense to me, but I never understood why PCGS was so tough on red coins that aren't perfectly "shiny", yet they'd give the same rb or bn coin a 65 all day.
By the pictures, lots of distractions in the fields, subdued luster...it's not very brilliant. I still would grade this a 65 on my scale any day.