Guess the Grade #545

1929-S NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

58

 

This poll and http://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-546.234175/ will be closing tonight.

Break time probably until the 28th, but the 24th is unlikely, but possible.

 

BTW, everyone give up?

 

63n1

 

Not sure how I missed these.

 

63, abstain, NGC will burn me!

 

I'm going 63 , but a 62 or 64 wouldn't surprise me .

 

63.

 

Is the '29-S known for weak strikes ?

 

Most all S mints from the 20 are noted for weak strikes. This one may not be as bad as the 25-S or 26-S, but it is a far cry from the later ones.

 

It has a real nice strike and I can find only one nick. So luster is not its strong suit but it is still descent. The color is really more uniform than my picture makes it seem. Maybe it isn't the prettiest coin I have ever seen, but still not a bad coin. NGC called it a 64. I don't know what else to call it. It would be one heck of a 63.

 

very over graded coin.

 

Why would you say that ? There's no wear just a strike probably from old or bad dies .

 

I see very little holding this back from 64... which attribute of grading would your reference in calling it over graded.