1925-D PCGS slabbed I will save you the trouble. It was graded. NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.
This coin has a lot going on, but one of them is not wear. I see no evidence of wear. The obverse color really looks like it has been cleaned, but it has luster. I can explain that because of the improper composition. The black spots on the shoulder are the result of the alloy mix also or at least they tend to follow the grain like an alloy mix. The strike on the reverse is nice, but the obverse leaves a bit to be desired. This should not affect the grade at this level. Oh, and that mark on the forehead is a scratch, but very hard to see in hand. Put all of this together with the wood grain and I am really surprised PCGS even graded it. I guess if all my assumptions are correct, it is a gradable coin and PCGS's 62 is certainly reasonable knowing their dislike of color variations.
I was thinking of 62 , just because how much PCGS hates woodies , still I couldn't see any wear on the obverse , but the left wheat talks had me a little worried , but figured correctly why would the left wear and the right didn't . Still not bad for me on a woody . only off by 1 high . I knew I should have lowered it another grade . Dick what do you think NGC would have given this coin ?
Something that wild, I would just be guessing, but I see no reason they would have graded it any different.
