In that neighborhood of a 58-60.. but I'll say because of some smoothness on the coat/jaw line/face I'll go with 58.
Start this off with this is a much better looking coin in hand. There is a fair amount of red in the recesses. Luster is pretty much in tact but not the booming luster of a red cent. Strike is full and the coin is nick free to the naked eye. That stain (?) below AMERICA is almost impossible to see in hand with or without a loupe. Even thought the rub is not as obvious in hand as it is in the picture, that is the only reason I see for their grade. PCGS only gave it a 62. I think I would be a bit more generous.