Guess the grade #459

1944- PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Hmmm....



Rims clear.

Prime focal areas and fields look clean.

Toning doesn't seem to impare luster and is attractive and multicolor. A bit of an odd distribution of color.

I'd value it like a 66r, but grade it 66rb. I guessed 6.

Interesting coin and I'm really not quite sure what to make of it.

 

I love that color , but I don't think PCGS does , I'd give it a 67 but PCGS probably went 66 .

 

Interesting color and a nice Lincoln MS-66RB

 

66

 

i'd say 67 all day, but then there's that nick behind the ear, so i'll drop it to 66

 

Love the color. I went with 66.

 

66

 

ms66rb

 

Lots of luster and nice color!

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t221119/ will be ending tonight!

 

I officially grade this coin WIWM.

Wish it Was Mine.

 

Dick that scratch to the right of liberty is on the slab , correct ?

 

went with the 66. very well may be a 67 thou

 

I really REALLY wanted to give this one a 67...but couldn't bring myself to do it. Can't see any hits at all!

 

I am missing something on this one. PCGS gave it a 65. The strike and (lack of) nicks could not keep it from a 67, IMO. I have seen better luster on some MS66's, but I have seen many 66's with a lot worse luster. I guess that means they did not like the eye appeal??

 

The only way I can see this coin getting a 65 is if that scratch to the right of Liberty is on the coin , even then it should have gotten a 66 , Guess PCGS doesn't like toned coins . I really think they blew this one . Well at least Dick got a beautiful coin for 65 money .

 

I paid more like 66 money for it, but still I would have had to pay that much more were it a 66. And that scratch is on the slab.

 

How could they not like the eye appeal??? That is a 66 easily!

 

I will usually subtract at least a half grade for strong toning at PCGS.