Guess the grade #456

1945-S PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms65

 

67

 

Beautiful strike , color and luster just that one hit on the reverse under the N .

 

Ms-66 rd

 

Is the mark under N on reverse on the slab or the coin? I believe the former, but wanted to ask.

 

Coin

 

Good thing I asked.

6r

 

MS-66 this one is very nice.

 

beautiful.. wanted to go 66n1, but unsure of the significance of the hit on the reverse and weight pcgs would have applied... so will guess it held it back to 66. LOVE the green woody toning !!

 

Went with 66 on this one

 

Cool....neon green slash toning. That's a pretty scarce form of toning, I've only seen maybe 4-5 Lincolns like that.

 

The question here is does the toning and reverse hit take off 3 or 4 points?

 

I love everything about this coin , the reverse hit doesn't bother me , but I have a feeling PCGS held it to a 66 , which would be rlms gain for getting a great coin a little cheaper .

 

That's a beauty Thad , is it yours ?

 

Voted 66. Nice coin!

 

ms-66 is my guess this time

 

66

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t220649/ will be ending tonight!

 

The stripes are not so bold in hand, but they are definitely there. Real solid strike, only a couple smaller nicks, and kind of a frosty luster. Were it not for that nick by the N (also not so obvious in hand, but there), I think this one had a shot at 67, but that nick is there. PCGS gave it a 66 and I agree.