Guess the grade #449

1931-S ANACS slabbed

I know it is ANACS, but I believe they were as conservative as either NGS or PCGS would be.

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That's a beauty! At first since it was ANACS (and the newer slabs as well), I thought I would be throwing a pot shot at the grade, but since you say it's graded as conservatively as NGC or PCGS I'll go with 63.

 

Ms-63 BN

 

Dick , now that's my favorite color cent and a beauty . ANACS that's a tough one , could you tell us the color or kind of slab ?

 

ANACS yellow slab, but I would not worry about who is grading the coin.

 

nice

 

Very nice, love the color and slight woodgrain!

 

63

 

I'm gonna go for it and say 64, but then again I can't really see the rims so it could be 58, so it's a shot in the dark here ... 64rb

 

I'm goin' with 64

 

I gave it a 64.

 

63rb

 

63

 

Looks like a nice 64 to me .

 

I almost forgot this;

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t219932/ will be ending tonight!

 

I like this coin. Kind of a wood grain (and you ask why I bought it) with a nice mahogany background. There are few nicks and descent luster left. I would think it deserves a 64. However ANACS only thought it only deserved a 63. Unless they thought the stripe by the date was a scratch (it is part of the grain), the only reason I can see for the 63 would be the erratic color. I suspect if ANACS gave it a 63, so would PCGS and NGC, but I still like it.

 

Maybe I'm starting to get a little groove going with this grading stuff.

 

My 1:1 right/wrong ratio still is working.

 

huh?

 

Get one right and one wrong. This has been going on for a while for me now.