Guess the grade #432

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I can't decide between 64 and 65. I'll suppose I'll give it a 65 since the reverse is beautiful.

 

64

 

went off on this one.... MS-66RD I see a nasty hit near Abe's chin but otherwise great fields and reverse

 

ms-66 is my guess

 

65 rb

 

I think I'll be within the old plus/minus one. LOL

 

The ole 64 + 1 . But then it is PCGS .

 

I said Gen./details because I think it looks cleaned... otherwise I was thinking 62

 

For all those who don't like NGC for their grading, try this one. Believe it or not, no one got the right answer. Great strike and the only really noticeable nick is on Abe's chin. The luster is not 67 luster but it that bad either. I would call it a 64+/65-. PCGS says I am wrong. They called it a 63. HUH?

 

Was going to go 64 , but nooooooooooooooo I had to give the extra point . lol

 

Duke has rejoined the group after a substantial absence. Where has everyone gone?

Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.
Irish2Ice 0.220 43
Duke Kavanaugh 0.316 20
Leadfoot 0.394 35
BadThad 0.400 47
bahabully 0.400 26
jcakcoin 0.448 31
rzage 0.462 41
mark_h 0.511 47
ldhair 0.522 24
Shoewrecky 0.524 22

 

Whoa I'm dropping like a rock , should have abstained like most everyone else . Actually I think they graded this too low .

 

Every grade covered except the correct one , and of course the elusive 68 . It would be funny if PCGS didn't blow it so bad .

 

Ugg.....missed both of these polls.........In all honesty I would have gotten #431 correct, but missed this one by AT LEAST one........64 and most probably 65 would have been my guess.

Dick, I think I've gotten so used to your "#### will be ending tonight" emails, that I just missed these. By the way, I can NOT see 63 with this coin. 64 is a hard maybe, but most likely 65, so I totally agree 64+/65-

 

Sorry for my absence RLM.
I always loved these and have helped my grading by doing them.

There were, and sometimes still is too many topics by 2 individuals started that are just time wasters. These have keep me away unfortunately. That coupled with I don't get email notices of topics that I type in being updated make it hard to keep up.

 

I was a bit tied up yesterday. I honestly thought that I had send out that reminder. It looks like I missed it. Sorry!

 

Whoa....off by 2! I'll need this one to drop out! I don't see this as less than a 64....tough grade IMO.

 

I've been struggling with some health issues and have missed a few rounds -- looks like you must have had some toughies.

Hope you all are doing well...Mike

 

You hope we are doing well? I hope you are better!