Guess the grade #423

1937-D PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms-67rd

 

I'm feelin 66 rd?

 

ms-66rd at pcgs im thinkin

 

65

 

Nice strike and luster , should go 67 . It has a slight woody look that I like but not sure how PCGS would go .

 

Talk about luster! 66!

 

Shoot me - NGC 67 and PCGS 66. Just my opinion.

 

66

 

66. I think I see the tiniest bit of wood :smile

 

Didn't really notice the week strike on Lincolns clothes and beard , wonder if '37-Ds are noted for that , high 66 or low 67 is the question , coins is relatively clean with great luster .

 

Great luster, hardly a hit.....NICE!

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t213928/ will be ending tonight.

 

Dead solid strike, nice luster, and just a few tiny nicks. Yes, it has a hint of wood grain to it. My only guess is that the grain along with the tiny nicks kept it from a 67. PGCS gave it a 66. I would rate it at least a 66+, but that grade did not exist back then.

 

Dick , 2 questions , 1. It looks like a week strike on his coat , is this normal for '37-Ds , 2. Did PCGS even give out any 67s for this date and MM ? Looking on Heritage , I couldn't find any 67s .

 

I have no idea why you thing that coat is weakly stuck. It is rock solid.
Caption for a 1937-D NGC 67 Heritage listing;

i.e. PCGS has 319 67's and 2 68's. BTW, Heritage has sold 101 of them.

 

PCGS nit picking to keep the 67 pop artificially high. This would be in an NGC 67 I'm will to bet.

 

It just looks like there's not much to the collar , almost like the neck runs into his coat . I agree the rest of the coin is well struck , it's just that one area I thought weak . Also I better learn how to use the search functions on Heritage better , I couldn't find any , which seemed odd to me . Thanks for the numbers .

 

You can select date (1937-D), grade (ms-67) and grading company (PCGS). That should pretty much cover it. I got 101 coins that way.

 

Thanks , about time I figure out how that works .