Guess the grade #42

1911-D PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That one looks like a 63 to me. TC

 

65 (remembering the look of the one I guessed 63 and it was 65)

 

63

 

62. That black spot on the reverse is very annoying.

 

63

What's up with the reverse rim?

 

The reverse rim is just about completely hidden by the slab. Is that what you are referring to?

 

Is the scratch from E in LIBERTY, to the back of his head on the holder?

 

62+2=MS64 BN (Almost RB) The spots on the reverse dropped it a couple in my opinion. I think the lines in the left field are die related since they appear to be raised.

 

64

 

I think that is what he's talking about because I see it too. Also I think it's a 64. Hopefully I will be able to get you an answer or a check out to you soon for the Wheats Dick..just been a little hectic with another oil spill.

 

Nice, that 11D is HAMMERED! 63BN

I'd give it a 64 easy with nice cartwheel luster. These are tough.

 

I will be closing these 2 tonight. See also http://www.cointalk.com/t122159/

 

61 I thought 62 and above have to have good luster, I don't see any. If I am incorrect let me know I can be trained

 

That is most of the purpose of these threads. BTW, this coin has pretty nice luster particularly for a brown coin.

 

Without that spot, this is every bit a 64+ and maybe a 65. I guess they though it only a small deduction. It was there when they graded it because I sent it in.

 

Not much changed this time.

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. Leadfoot 0.586 31
2. ddoomm1 0.611 19
3. bahabully 0.657 37
4. mark_h 0.667 38
5. ldhair 0.686 37
6. BadThad 0.730 39
7. abe 0.750 13
8. Duke Kavanaugh 0.914 37
9. tmoneyeagles 0.939 35
10. WashQuartJesse 1.000 31

 

Figures....the breaks of picture grading.

Nice coin!!!!

 

TY and I understand about the grading from pictures. At least I think I am giving you pictures that you can have a good idea what you are doing.

 

The images are darn good if you ask me.