Guess the grade #398

1952-S PGCS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'm liking what I'm seeing at a 66

 

That scratch by the C in CENT kept me down to 64.

 

my standards 65, PCGS 66

 

MS65 RD, 66 is possible however

 

65

 

ANother one that looks clean enough on the obverse to grade 67, but luster looks a touch muted, so I guessed 66.

 

not liking the reverse but MS-67RD

 

Obverse is beautiful , but the reverse will hold it down I voted 66 a couple days ago , but the more I look at the reverse and it being in a PCGS slab I wouldn't be suprised at a 65+ .

 

I don't think the revese field hits would cost more than -4 pts.

 

ms-64, reverse looks to drop it from gem, imo

 

Thought the same thing, but dropped from 67 to 66. Voted 66rd as I'm betting in hand the "nicks" around the O in One is not as noticeable.

 

All I know is I love the coin , I don't think the nicks around the one are as bad as in the pics but it's that one big hit on the O at 12 o:clock that has me a little worried , but It should make a 66 .

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t210104/ will be ending tonight.

 

Super strike and nice luster. The obverse in virtually nick free and would probably make a 67 even at PCGS, but the nicks around ONE CENT brings that back real quick. PCGS called it a 66 and that is probably right.

 

No comment! BTW, he has only missed 2 of the last 25 so the worst (best?) is yet to come.

Top 11. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. Irish2Ice 0.154 41
2. bahabully 0.276 31
3. ldhair 0.382 36
4. Leadfoot 0.387 33
5. ddoomm1 0.412 18
6. BadThad 0.432 46
7. rzage 0.436 41
8. Shoewrecky 0.440 26
9. mark_h 0.450 42
10. jcakcoin 0.489 47

 

glad to be back in the rankings after a long period of 'no-votes,'

btw, who is​ this Irish2Ice guy

 

Hey ddoomm, My name is Bob.

 

0.154 That's got to be one of the lowest scores . Congrats Irish21ce , and bahabullys score is darn good too . Next are 2 hard coins , bet they're all over the place .

 

Hi Bob!!! My name is Dominik haha. As for the next 2 I gave them both MS-67RD (but they are those annoying examples were's its like hey what is the difference between a MS-66RD and MS-67RD, especially considering that grading is based largely on rational opinion :/)