Guess the grade #383

1912-D PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

tough call here those are dark pictures though that is a really nice look 12-d..

 

58 but unsure

 

Au55

 

i'm in the au-58 club, but could be low MS

 

hmm this is a tricky one, I could not tell a whole lot from the pics (especially the obverse, but hey the brown color does not help) soooo MS-62BN

 

Oh ya....back to the old stuff.

 

Don't care what that coin grades, I grade it delicious. Superb coin.

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t208599/ will be ending tonight. I am not sure when (or possibly if) I will get a new round or even answers up.

 

Wear = AU58

 

I want to go with 64 but the reverse bugs me. Can't really tell what's going on.
This may kill me but, 64 is my vote. Heck, Doug gave it a 63

 

I should skip this one , but no guts no glory . I see no wear so I'll say 64 .

 

Talk about all over the board , 60 and 61 are still open .

 

This coin has very nice luster, very few nicks, and a strike that leaves little to be desired. I am not sure even with a loupe if the color variations obviously there are a result of rubs or merely contact toning, but that is the only reason I can see for them not to give this a 64. Instead, they only gave it a 62.

 

Dang I thought for sure it was at least a 63 and gave it a 64 . Talk about tough on a coin .

 

5 points low? My inner Doug is calling!

 

LOL , At least you'll get to drop this score , that has to be your largest miss .

 

So the file name was the grade. I thought it was better than that. Ouch, that hurt.

 

Sweet....I got two in a row,,,but no bump in the standings. ARRGGGG, I need to drop a bad guess soon!

 

Hummmm....Dick doesn't usually slip up like that. I should pay attention to those names in case he does! LOL