This and http://www.cointalk.com/t207751/ will be ending tonight. Assuming I can add pictures, I will start another round.
I went 65. Not seeing any marks that would take it to 64. Love the rich looking color of the reverse.
Strike, luster, and nicks are not a problem. Were that the only criteria, this would be a solid 66. However, there are many light blotches on the coin. Considering it is a RB coin, I think 65 is a fair grade.
Very nice coin Dick! I love the look of it, nice deep red color. Just not enough flash to make 66 I guess. There's hardly a hit on this coin though.