Guess the grade #372

1955-S NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

67rd

 

Insane luster!

 

Nice coin.

 

Very nice coin. Luster does indeed boom, but the ticks bother me a little. I'm unsure of my indecision......lol

 

It's got the strike and luster for a 67 , but that reverse bothers me .

 

66 IMO, 67 in NGC's mind

 

Ms-65 rd

 

i say ms-65...i think

 

Dick , how are those marks on the reverse in hand ? Barley noticible or reall stick out ?

 

There are hardly any marks (nicks) on the reverse to stick out. So, no, they are not particularly noticeable.

 

Thanks , then I'm going 67 .

 

67

 

I guessed 67, but I would not be surprised if NGC gave it a 66. It reminds me of the 57-d examples in 66 recently posted.

 

I agree Mike , this one could go either way .

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t207005/ will be ending tonight.

 

I second that.

 

Yes, the obverse has great luster. It is a bit chippy, but I could see a 67 with that luster. Yes, the marks on the reverse are barely visible. However, did anyone notice the obvious difference in luster between the obverse and the reverse? Maybe if the reverse had the luster of the obverse, it would have a 67, but it does not. NGC gave it a 66and I agree.

 

ldhair still holding the lead and little has changed below him - again.

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. ldhair 0.355 33
2. Leadfoot 0.444 38
3. BadThad 0.452 44
4. Shoewrecky 0.483 30
5. rzage 0.500 40
6. jcakcoin 0.543 48
7. Irish2Ice 0.561 43
8. Cazkaboom 0.609 48
9. mark_h 0.619 44
10. bahabully 0.679 29

 

The luster is great, but the reverse looks dead. 66



oh, I am late. Still, that is my opinion.