Guess the grade #362

1936-S NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I think they hand out 66's on these like candy. Luster looks to have mellowed with a slight red toning. Almost no hits but the weakness in AMER may hold it back if the graders were grumpy.

 

Looks like a 64 coin with 66 luster. I'll settle in between with a 65.

 

I'm thinking 65 .

 

It really should be a 65, but it's a 66 in NGC's mind

 

Ms65rd

 

I like it as 65. The luster is nice and pretty clean fields. Weakness in the letters, but I've seen 66's with worse. Gotta go 66RD

 

I've been getting killed giving the extra point , but I'm still going 66 on this one .

 

66 right here.

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t206034/ will be ending tonight.

 

Tough to judge the luster on this one. 66

 

Nice strike and only a few tiny nicks. This coin could easily pass for a 67 (don't I wish), but it is a dirty amber in color and luster is not its strong suit. I am not sure just how they balance all of those , but NGC came up with a 66 and that sound reasonable to me.

 

ddoomm1 has apparently given up so has rejoin in his absence.

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. ldhair 0.300 32
2. BadThad 0.372 45
3. Leadfoot 0.421 40
4. Shoewrecky 0.500 38
5. rzage 0.543 37
6. jcakcoin 0.565 48
7. Cazkaboom 0.596 49
8. swhuck 0.625 34
9. mark_h 0.643 44
10. bahabully 0.647 36