Guess the grade #36

1943-S NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted

BTW, the lines on the reverse are die polish lines

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

64

 

64

 

I guess MS64. TC

 

Me thinks 64 as well

 

65, prob a 66, but hard to tell if marks are on the holder or not.

 

63+2=ms65 black?

 

I guessed 66, but the more I look at it, I think 67. Regardless, I wonder if the milk spots were on the coin when graded.

 

I'll go 65, although if they weren't there at the time of grading, it wouldn't surprise me at a higher grade.

 

I'm still betting this coin has blinding luster so it was graded at 66 regardless of any other blemishes.

 

This poll will close tomorrow night. So will http://www.cointalk.com/t120782/

 

Think that's a 65 (nice pictures btw RLM)

 

Yea, Dick's pictures ROCK.

 

Thanks for the comments. Maybe it has a lot to do with the fact that this is silver (color, anyway) rather than copper.:thumb:

BTW, I am not too sure just when I will get these updated. I will be returning home this evening. :smile

 

I say 65

 

I have not idea how they judge those spots nor if they were there when it was graded. Aside from that, that is a coin is a solid 67 from luster, marks and strike.

 

In all honesty I deducted for the spots - I was not sure what a tpg would do over them.

 

Got a new leader.
You now need 9 guesses to qualify for the leaders. Only 21 qualify.
There are now 164 participants with at least 1 guess although 60 have only one guess.


Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. Leadfoot 0.565 25
2. mark_h 0.600 32
3. ddoomm1 0.625 17
4. bahabully 0.655 31
5. ldhair 0.655 31
6. BadThad 0.677 33
7. abe 0.750 13
8. Duke Kavanaugh 0.897 31
9. tmoneyeagles 0.931 31
10. WashQuartJesse 1.000 25

 

As I said, I don't know either - even if they were there.

 

OUCH....this one hurt! 2 grades off!