great luster, but a couple marks on the reverse. I think I will risk saying 65, which is a number I rarely like to use, unless, of course, it is my coin.(JK)
LOVE that deep red color! But, I have to agree with Doug to a certain degree. MS66 coin with shot at 67 had it not been for the scratches.
Abstain. This looks like a "sucker" coin in that I think the grade and coin may disagree -- and I'm not going to guess.
Deep red coin with just a few tiny ticks. There are also a few very tiny dark spots. I have no idea if they were there at grading or not, but they are so small, I doubt they made much difference. FWIW, the larger dark areas (as on the chin and shoulder) are shine rather than off color. I really like the color. PCGS wound up at a 66. I don't think there is enough there for a 67, so 66 looks right to me.
ldhair and ddoomm1 flip-flopped, but everyone else pretty much stay just as they were. Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses. ldhair 0.348 25 ddoomm1 0.357 30 BadThad 0.415 43 Leadfoot 0.442 45 jcakcoin 0.522 48 Shoewrecky 0.524 44 mark_h 0.556 47 rzage 0.559 36 Cazkaboom 0.600 47 swhuck 0.614 46