Guess the grade #341

1937- NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

66 again...like the toning on that coin. To bad there are those carbon spots on the obverse and reverse.

 

66 all day.

 

67 luster on it, but the reverse spots bring it down to a 66.

 

Ms66 rd

 

67 luster, 66 cheek, 66- reverse. I guessed 66.

 

Nice coin.

 

67 obverse, nice halo luster.

 

Great luster , but too many marks on face shoulder and reverse to make 67 , 66 .

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t203897/ will be ending tonight.

 

I always wonder how bad those spots are in hand , if they're not that bad I can see a 67 .

 

63 on this one. I don't like the stuff on the reverse.

 

Nice luster and a solid strike. The fields are mark free so far as I can tell I will bet those marks on the reverse were not there when it was graded. Without them, I could easily see a 67 and that is what NGC gave it. With them ....?

 

Luster wins again, it's a blazer!

 

Dick , how bad do those marks look in hand ?

 

How do you describe that? They are not blatant. They are definitely not enough to call it RB. However, they are definitely there. Is there such a thing as medium bad?

 

So they're probably bad enough to influence the grade . Thanks , just wondering .

 

Guess The Grade

Beautiful Luster and eye appeal some problem with nicks..... I would call it a MS65+ in fact I would bump it up to a MS66, real nice coin.