Guess the grade #328

1954- NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Is the "cleaning" on the reverse pic on the coin or the slab?

 

I assume you are talking about the lines. They are on the coin, but look real close before you jump to any conclusions.

 

66 only because of the lack of luster and the couple nicks on the cheeks on the coin else it would be a 67.

 

65

 

MS66 RD, way too many hits for a 67,

 

66 rd

 

split between 66 and 67. went with 66 because of the hits on cheek and jawline, along with remnants of die polish suggesting the luster isn't as booming, for example, as the other coin this week.

 

65. Too many minute ticks. Of course with the right lighting and photography, you could make it look better than it is.

 

My first thoughts were genuine, but you wouldn't buy a genuine coin? I'd have to say 65RD, would make a fine 67 darn...

 

Ms-66rd

 

Especially with the spots on the reverse , 66 .

 

gotta go 65rd

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t201736/ will be ending tonight.

Note; There will be a pause at least until next Wednesday or likely the following Saturday. This Saturday's scores may well be late.

 

I was torn between 65 and 66; neither would surprise me.

 

Again, it is mostly in the pictures. Another case of you cannot see them on the reverse in hand. However, they are actually worse on the obverse and you can actually make something out on that side. Super strike and great luster, but a couple nicks and a bit of dirty color keep it at a 66. Apparently the lines had little effect on the grade.

 

52 rounds ago, there was a 10-S that you had problems grading. Since those score went away this time, those of you who guessed probably got a nice jump in score. BadThad is our new leader, but for such a change in the scoring, there was surprisingly few changes in the rest of the standings

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. BadThad 0.366 43
2. ldhair 0.370 29
3. rzage 0.389 38
4. ddoomm1 0.444 47
5. swhuck 0.458 50
6. mark_h 0.477 46
7. bahabully 0.500 50
8. jcakcoin 0.500 48
9. Shoewrecky 0.522 48
10. Leadfoot 0.535 45

 

Dick , how about a pick of that '10-S , or a link to it . I can't find it .

 

Here you go; http://www.cointalk.com/t194076/

 

In first.....at least until the next round. LOL

Thanks Dick