Guess the grade #315

1940-D NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

66 rd imo

 

are those carbon spots on the obverse (left side, underneath the word liberty and to left of lincoln's head)? that is a great looks reverse

 

Small one on his vest, but nothing by LIBERTY.

 

PCGS MS65 all day long IMO....I really like it at 65+. LDS luster probably bumped it.

 

Spotted or not spotted at grading, that is the question....

I'll guess it was graded as-is and graded 65.

FWIW, I grade it as-is at 64.

 

Ngc= 66

 

I'm gonna have to buck the trend here and say 64. The obverse is just to "muddy" with small nicks and dings for me to comfortably mark it much higher. Still a beauty over all though.

 

I voted 66 but could be a 67.

 

I wish I could change my vote. I initially saw the knicks and assumed it was circulated... Since it's not, I'll say 64.

 

It'd have a shot at a 67 except for the obverse spots IMO.

 

Tough call, because I think the reverse is nicer than the obverse. I voted 65 though.

 

MS66 RD, a 65 is possible

 

66rd for me.
Don't like the spot by TRUST or would have gone 1 higher.

 

the pics appear to be a bit dark but I'll say its good enough for a MS-66

 

I guessed 66 cause of the reverse. I think if the whole coin looked like the obverse it would be a 64 though

 

Sorry I am running behind, but this and http://www.cointalk.com/t200334/ will be ending SOON!

 

I probably should not have listed this one, but it is too late now. Great strike and nearly mark free. No problem with the luster, but there are those spots. I can assure you they were not there when it was graded. Anyhow, NGC called it a 67. Did it deserve it when they graded it, probably. Just look at that reverse. Does it deserve it today, not really.

 

Whoa!

 

Gave the 66 a 67 and the 67 a 66 , lol .