I had to go with the obverse fields as pictured, may they are better in hand...but I can't tell. The reverse is 66, I'd call it 65+ with that reverse and the overall lack of hits. I'm betting some flashy luster, I see some orange peel on the obverse from LDS.
I guessed 5r, but a 6 would not surprise me -- wondering if the discoloration on the obverse was there at grading time. I would expect the LDS to have very nice luster....
I am kind of torn on this one. There are a lot on nicks and spots, but they are all small. The strike and luster are solid. I would have thought it would go 65, but PCGS only though a 64. BTW, you did a lot better before. See http://www.cointalk.com/t112537/.
It's the obverse fields, too many distractions. I thought the later die state luster and lack of hits would take it up one...that's a nice coin.
