1870-S 50C: AU53 1892 50C: MS62 PL 1913-S 5C: MS62 1919 25C: AU Details Questionable Color 1919-D 10C: XF40 1920 25C: MS62 (has a good shot at FH but I'm gonna say it misses) 1921 50C: MS63 (looks dipped and unnatural to my eye) 1929 5C: MS Details Questionable Color (But I hope it gets MS66*) 1938-D 5C: MS65* (needs better luster for premium gem) 1943-S: MS66
1870-S 50c AU-55 1892 50c MS-62PL 1913-S 5c AU-55 1919 25c AU-58 (Possible Details for QC) 1919-D 10c AU-53 1920 25c MS-62FH 1921-D 50c MS-63 1929 5c MS-65 1938-D/D RPM-#2 MS-63 (I just don't see much luster on this one) 1943-S MS-66 Wow, @Lehigh96 and I were pretty much in line with each other on this one.
Results XF45 UNC Details MS62 AU Details AT AU53 MS62FH Unc Details Wheel mark Unc Details Wheel Mark AU Details Whizzed MS66 Star
I don't understand either of the two Unc Details Wheel Mark grades, but other than that, I nailed some of these grades.
The Columbian and Lincoln were my coins. Very disappointed in the Columbian as I cracked it out of a straight graded ANACS holder. The Lincoln I was almost certain would go PL but I crossed from a PCGS 66 holder so I am happy with the star.
only 6 of the total coins were mine. The rest were piggybacks. For me my 1919-D Dime didn't get the FB designation I was hoping for. I did submit a crossover last minute as another was crossing his 66 PL Lincoln which came back 66 Star. It was a PCGS XF45 1843-O Seated Half, it came back from NGC as a AU53. The 1870-S Seated half I bought raw on eBay for $120, while my 1910-J Germany 3 Mark came back AU58. My Morgan sadly only came back as a MS63, I was hoping for at least a star. My 1956-D Didn't get the Star, so that was a wasted $20... Overall I'm happy.... some of the people I submitted for not so much.
Besides the AT quarter (which is obvious from a mile away), the pictures you posted didn't really show cleaning or whizzing. Are these evident in hand? Were the pictures glamour shots that just didn't show the problems? I wouldn't have guessed "whizzed" from these pics, but I trust their in-hand evaluation. Can you post more honest pics that show the problems?
My calls were 1870-s au-55 1892 ms 63 1913-s au 55 1919 unc details q.c tho I’d love it if it ever got a straight grade 1919-d au 50 1920 au 58 1921 ms 63 1929 q.c ms 64 if straight 1938 qc ms 66 if straight 1943 ms 65
I don’t get the wheel mark or the whizzed grades. Could just be bs grades Cause they just don’t want to holder them. Pcgs does the same
