Guess the Grade - 1885-S Morgan

Please guess the grade on this 1885-S Morgan. Bonus points for guessing the type of holder. Thank you!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'll say MS64. It's in a plastic holder.

Chris

 

Either one or two of your statements are correct!

 

Are you sure I don't have three right? I'm almost positive that I spelled my name correctly.

Chris

 

My apologies! You have anywhere from one to three correct statements in that original post!

 

Now you're really confusing me. First, you said that I have "1 or 2" correct. Then, when I cited the spelling of my name, you said I have "1 to 3" correct. So, if I had one correct to begin and added my name, I should have "2 or 3" correct. Right?

I'll tell you what. I'm gonna change my guess.

MS65
Plastic holder
Chris

Now, how many do I have right?

 

Sorry for the confusion!
You were correct about it being 2 to 3 (although if you had 2 to 3 right, saying you had anywhere from 1 to 3 right would still be true).

By the way, how long do you think we can go back and forth like this before someone else guesses a grade?

 

I guess all of the kiddies went to bed. I'll probably stay up until 3 or 4 am, going back and forth between the TV and the computer. You still haven't told me how many I have correct with my new guesses.

MS65
Plastic holder
Chris

 

She is a frosty 63

 

Now it is 2; your previous attempt was 2 to 3 (I don't want to reveal it completely).

 

63PL

 

I am going with Ms 64 PL.
Second generation PCGS.

 

MS 63 PL
PCGS holder

 

MS64 and OGH but with the outside part broken off and what's left looks like a rattler but it's not

 

MS64. Wish I had an MS example of this date. PCGS plastic.

 

I'm guessing MS-64 in a PCGS either Doily or the 2.1 Doily replacement holder. Anything earlier would not have the retaining ring around the outside and the later versions moved the PCGS logo to the lower right corner of the holder rather than the retaining ring.

 

Ms 64....dont know the hokder

 

ms63 with a great backside.

 

MS64PL?

 

MS-65 ... PCGS Holder