Guess the Grade - 1885 Morgan

Another Morgan, another Guess the Grade...






Here is another photo of the obverse:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Is the purple hue's in the back ground? or are they part of the toning?

 

MS63, maybe PL if it's a real old holder

 

There is some rim toning on both sides, but I believe the purple that you see is just a shadow or reflection from the camera.

 

63 PL fatty holder?

 

Yes an NGC fatty ...it goes nice with the PCGS rattler from my other thread

 

I am in at 63 because of the chatter below he chin, If it was just the field?
Gotta love those old ANACS holders!
Edit_- missed that one!

 

I think it's a 63 with a possible PL added. The rim toning looks like it could be really nice.

 

I concur- 63 with a shot PL

 

63

 

Like the rest, a 63 with nice luster.
But no pl

 

MS63+

 

MS63

 

62PL old fatty

 

Dang, everyone is on point today. I concur with the others at 63, and I'll say no PL.

P.S. The obverse rim toning near the date is off the chain!

 

Ms-36

 

MS 63 as well. To many contact marks on the obverse.

 

I believe my photos showed the marks quite pominently. What if I had used this obverse picture:

 

Im still at 63 on account of the long prominent scratch in the prime focal area.
Are you saying it graded out higher??

 

The grade is MS 62 PL; at some angles you can't see any hits.
To me it looks as nice as many MS 63 or 64 pieces. The photos also don't show it too well, but the coin has prooflike features (maybe not enough for today's standards, but it would be close).