Guess the grade #16

1910-S NGC slabbed


NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

64 lol I missed the big spot on reverse so 62

 

Au58

 

Au58. Tc

 

Whew,, these are always tough... I see what appears to be some rub above the ear and on cheek and jaw,, some dirt on reverse but good details. Probably a 58, with a semi-key date bump... so went 60.

 

See also #15 http://www.cointalk.com/t116471/

 

I had to go with MS60...it looks pretty beat up (perhaps a lotta album rub), but not circulated (imo).

 

58, but I think I guessed low.

 

I'll go with the 58 crowd...

 

58 because of the rubbing on the high parts of the coin.

 

AU55 for me. I don't like the spots on the reverse plus the wear on the obv.

 

63

 

Au58

 

55, apparent rub on obverse, general circulation signs.

 

I'm going with AU55 only because AU Details - Damaged/Corrosion is not a choice. This means it will probably come back a 60 if my grading trend continues.

 

I am going to end this poll tomorrow. Guess the grade #17 will also end tomorrow http://www.cointalk.com/t116471/.

 

WOW! NGS thought it was unc, but only 7 did here. I can only guess with a reverse that appears clean, NGC said it was album friction and passed it as unc. The pictures bring it out more than in hand, but it is there.

 

Yup,, I saw that coming... those good pics show light rubs a bit more roughly than in hand.... but then again, I've see the roughly the same condition coin in a 53 and 55 and 58 and 60 and 61 and obviously, 62. Love em',,, they really move the overall scores around a bit.

 

These last 3 were tough in my opinion. Sometimes really hard to see weak strike versus the slight rub. One of the toughest things to do in pictures at time. Anyway I enjoy the threads.

 

62 so wha?
RLM, I'm really slipping on your guess the grades...either that or NGC/PCGS is really slipping at grading...