Guess the grade #100

1957-D PCGS slabbed

Round #100#

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Probably went 65, but I wouldn't give it more than a 64.

 

Some small scratces on obverse, 63

 

Some scrsthes on obverse, 63

 

Recent overgrading has me conservative. I guessed 65.

 

65...great luster but just to many hits to break that 66..

 

64

 

I am going to close this and http://www.cointalk.com/t135775/ tomorrow.

 

Most of you thought this a 65. PCGS did not. I don't know. First off, 2 of those "marks" are die cracks (one on each side) and most of the rest of the marks are rather small. The luster is not a problem. Maybe they just weren't visible enough to the graders (naked eyes!).

 

Foiled again!

 

Got some new entries into the top. And Duke actually missed one, but then most did.

Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.
Duke Kavanaugh 0.409 46
Coinguy56 0.481 29
bahabully 0.500 50
swhuck 0.512 43
Leadfoot 0.532 49
ddoomm1 0.564 41
mark_h 0.604 50
BadThad 0.667 50
Shoewrecky 0.677 33
jallengomez 0.719 34

 

Luster wins!

 

that's the most aggressive 65 in that date I've seen from pcgs..... there are obvious hits,, even in the fields..... must have been a big $ batch submission and maybe this one was one of those awarded bonus points... ; )