GTG with a twist - Morgan edition

Is the twist that there are three Morgans to grade? No.
Is the twist something in this line***? No.
Is there really a twist? I don't know or do I?

Please guess:
1)


2)


3)





***(Line 2 only included in order to get me to three lines)

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

MS-64
MS-64*
MS-65

 

64
65
65

 

MS64+
MS65*
MS65*

 

Feel free to also comment on which one you all think deserves the highest grade.

 

My guess is that if the obverse of 2 was with the reverse of 3, I would really like that best.

 

We all have different tastes, but my guess is that the reverse of #2 would be chosen by most as the best. That one has another photo:

 

True, but I like it more subtle in this case. That one ^^ is a monster tone, yet I am not in love with the way the colors lay down.

 

64+
64*
64

All sweet coins

 

Fair enough...like I said we all have different tastes and that is what makes it fun.

 

64
64+*
64+

 

I'll go with
64
65
64
I like coin #2 the most.

 

I love the color of that reverse.

 

64
63
64

 

Even though the toning is not my preference, I think 2 got a bump up in grade for it and it would not surprise me to see it in a 65* or 66-66* slab. And overall, it probably does deserve the highest grade of the three. Both 1 and 2 have obverses that may hold them back.

 

64
65 due to toning bump
64

 

62, 63, 64

 

+1

The twist is that the coin with the most focal distraction is graded the highest.
Sometimes the contact is less visible to the eye, but really pops out in a photo.

 

coin 1: 64
coin 2: 63
coin 3: 65

 

64
65
66