Looks gem to me from the photos. Probably a 66. Theres quite a lot of gem 38-D coins, so I'm decently confident.
I see it as a nice MS-66. I cherrypicked a really nice unattributed MS-67 a few years ago. That is a fun one to cherrypick. I have a feeling you did the same.
Hi Paddy, What a great image of a four legged Buff. It looks to me like the Indian is crying over the mass slaughter of his tribes next meal. Great mint mark error. MS65 at least. Dave
Well if you guessed a 65 thats what NGC gave it...it was back in the day that NGC was known for tightly grades on nickels. I give it a 66 ...but no matter a sweet specimen with a very cool variety...