Here's another toned Irish shilling I got. This time, the first year for the type in proof. Can you guess the grade issued by NGC on this 1928 Ireland Shilling proof coin? I added my other Irish shillings to this thread, too, as more-or-less a reference to how NGC grades these particular coins. Now I just need to decide which one to keep... Good Luck! 1928 Ireland Shilling Proof 1942 Ireland Shilling #1: MS-63 1942 Ireland Shilling #2: MS-65
Have to be a WAG from me. I wouldn't have thought it was a proof and I prefer your 63 over the 65. I would say 64 but I wouldn't be surprised to be off by 3 points higher or lower.
Wait you're right, I switched the two grades. Whoops! The MS-65 is the first one. The second is MS-63. And, yeah it's probably due to my photography skills, or lack thereof. I tried to take some better photos. Maybe these are a little better (?). The second set of photos is of the MS-63 1942 Ireland Shilling to show how it looks slabbed.