I'm at a 64 with an outside chance at a 65. My first instinct was semi-PL. I can't believe that was in a DMPL holder. Does it even look PL to you?
I think she looks PL and if the grader is feeling gracious that day could go DMPL. As far as grade I took the advice of a well respected person who viewed it in person along with a dealer who both felt an easy 64PL maybe 64DMPL.
Huh, the DMPL holder has me wondering.... Was the holder wrong, or are your pictures not showing the mirrors? I would be *really* surprised if a DMPL didn't even cross as PL..... I will amend my guess to 64PL, although your initial pictures don't really show it. Quick check of the NGC price guide shows 63DPL at $260, and 64PL at $275. Granted, these prices are probably somewhat optimistic, but the fact remains that PCGS will almost always garner a stronger price than ANACS at the same grade (old holder or not). An old ANACS holder will usually be worth more than a new ANACS holder (why would anyone submit to ANACS today?). All told, crossing a 63DPL ANACS (with the value suppressed by the ANACS) to a 64PL PCGS (with the value helped by the PCGS) would result in a pretty decent "value" gain. Yes, I realize that its the exact same coin for two arbitrarily different prices. The clothes make the man... or the Morgan.
