Grade opinions/guesses on these 3 1880-s morgan dollars

I'm quite thrilled with these.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Morgan 2

 

Morgan 3

 

Id give the first one a 64 with a soft stike on the reverse.

Ruben

 

this Id give a 63

 

I like this one the best, but I'd give it a 64.

Ruben

 

How about 64 , 64, 65.

 

I think the first one is a 65.

 

you guys are being brutal.

 

Too brutal? How about SGS grades? They're all MS70 DMPL's =)

 

OK, I'm going 64, 64 (maybe 65) and 65...

 

WOWzer! I'm gonna go out oon a limb and say 68,67, 68 respectively. Holy crap dude. AWESOME!!!!
hya: :bow: :bow: :bow:

 

(I should work for NTC!!)

 

you are hands down the closest yet. :smile

 

Look like 3 66's to me...Mike

 

Now reading the rest of the responses, and to the guesser's defense, those photos are both too small as well as lit in such a way as it is difficult to distinguish between luster breaks and hits/marks (which is the major difference between 63/64 coins and 65/66+ coins). Not to rag on the photos, as I know how hard Morgan's are to photo, but I can see how the grade guesses are all over the place.....Mike

 

Mike, I completely agree. I'll try to get some better pictures up. I am buying a new camera this week.

 

It is always difficult to tell from pictures, but I would guess they are MS-66, MS-65, and MS-65 in that order.

 

zaneman:
nice pictures, but, I don't understand can't you just read the labels for the grades?
[Just kidding!]
nice coins, I'd go 5, 5, 6.

 

I'll reveal the grades. They are all graded ms-67. I believe the first may have claims to an 8, the second just made 7 IMO, and the 3 is a nice 67. The photos really were pretty crappy. My new camera should be here Wednesday. I'll post better pictures then, and if I don't please feel free to remind me.