Grade opinions/guess the grade on this 3-legged buffalo

What do you guys think of this one (not mine)?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I would venture a 65 with die fatigue.

 

yeah i have to agree i would say from the photo its a 63 because you dont see these in 62 its either 61 or 63 with buffalos and its nicer than a 61

 

I was leaning towards 61

 

grading buffs can be plain hard. I will say I can't see hardly any marks and it has a good strike, i'd say ms 65-66.
I am curious of the actual grade. very nice coin.

 

well since its zane, I'll give it a 72

 

Ms-64

 

I'll go with 63.

 

i don't mean to be a party pooper but me gives it a 60

grizz

 

I would say MS 63. The strike seem a bit weak. But a nice coin over all.

Lou

 

My first reaction: MS-WOW.

Second: MS-63.
NGC

 

A very very nice ms-63 in my opinion

 

well the reverse seems well struck to my noobie eye but i see what you guys ar esaying on the obverse i dont see much marks so i could venture a 64-65 but i dont understand why people are calling it a 60 or 61

 

Thanks for the input everyone. My opinion of the coin is it is a PQ ms-63. Now here is the kicker, it is an anacs au-50 holder. I know the individual who purchased it, and I'm excited to see what it comes back as after a regrade.

 

here is a picture of it in the holder.

 

Did it come back yet ?

 

A better question might be "did he come back yet?"

 

haha.. good answer RLM.