This was in the Erie paper today: :Someone jammed the Coinstar machine at the West 26th Street Tops Market with a number of old coins. The Coinstar can take a penny, nickel, dime, quarter, half dollar and a Sacagawea dollar coin. It's not designed to take a 1890's Morgan Silver Dollar worth about $500. Outside the grocery store police recoved a backpack filled with empty coin holders."
Reminds me of a story about how a stolen Strativarius cello nearly ended up getting turned into a CD case by someone who found it. Luckily he though better of it and called the police instead.
Update: Today's paper (Sunday) says they found the collector who is missing the coins and the coins were recovered from the machine. Also, they have some leads on who stole the coins. I wish I could make some coinstar machines, I'd make a percentage and also get to search for coins. Hope there is a collector at the coinstar facility.