Does this 8 Reales look genuine?

I bought this coin in the mid to late 90's during a Navy port visit to San Juan, Puerto Rico. I later showed it to a dealer who told me that it weighed out correctly but still wasn't sure about authenticity. I'm thinking about putting it on EBay but don't want to unknowingly list a fake, as there are already enough of those for sale with me adding to the problem.

What do you guys think? Also, if it is genuine, does the Potosi mint mark carry a premium?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Looks good to me what's it weight ?

 

Not sure but I can try to weigh it tomorrow at work. What should it weigh?

 

27.2638 grams, minimum 26.8646 also looks good to me.

 

Pretty common date and MM and nothing looks wrong to me. You might do better locally than eBay, probably won't get more than $40-50 either way so save the 12%.

 

Bolivia 8 Reales KM #73
1799PTS PP

edited

 

It weighed in at 26.68g. Is that definitely underweight even considering the wear?

 

So is it even worth asking Dan Sedwick for an opinion if the weight is truly a show stopper? Perhaps the coin is still worth something if it is a contemporary counterfeit, or if there are specific dates and or mints that were underweight?

 

Looks good to me but the photos sure hurt my neck. Clear enough though.

 

Pretty coin, and

I'm guessing not many counterfeits in the 90s. Pretty coin. I just sent (2) 1753, 1763 to NGC that graded VF details. Yours by comparison should be much higher, say XF?

 

Look at the pillars on the reverse. One should be able to read the inscription PLVS ULTRA (more beyond). With the PLVS heavily worn off the left pillar, and almost equal wear on the right, I think the actual condition closer to a fine +. The wear looks pretty even, including the rim, somewhat harder to fake. If it were to pass the magnet test and it also were dated to before 1781, I would have bought it at a price of about $45 and thought it a good addition to my collection of coinage used by the Revolutionary War era. By the way, I have found more variation in weight for these coins than one might imagine.

 

Hard to say through not really good photograhs, but...I do not like the coin, specially the rim. Weight is good enough.

Potosi problem was around year 1640

 

I just emailed Dan Sedwick with a link to this thread and photos of the coin. I'm curious to hear his response. Even if the coin is fake I'm definitely enjoying and learning from this discussion.

 

Okay, drum roll, here's what I got from Dan...

 

wow.

 

Congratulations...always get more than one opinion.

 

Very Nice! Congrats, its always fun to find genuine Spanish silver!