Did PCGS make a mistake???

This Capped Bust Half looks like a cleaned VF-20 to me. Do you think PCGS overgraded it and missed the cleaning?

Charlie

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Tough to tell from the scans, but I wouldn't give the coin XF-45. EF-40 at the most and probably should only be a VF-35.

 

You mean like this one??

 

Ah come on Midas....you can say it once that yes PCGS messed up....we won't tell anyone!!

Charlie...yes I think they did....both overgrade and miss a cleaning!

Speedy

 

If that coin was cleaned (not saying it wasn't), then all the TPGs grade and slab cleaned coins like that. And yes, XF45 is definitely too high for that coin. If I was looking to buy it, I don't think I'd pay over VF money for it.

 

hahaha zaneman already screwed one up

 

That was one of the ones Hall "personally walked thru" the grading room with to make sure his graders were being fair and not giving dealers associated with the organization any breaks.

Bone