Just recently started roll searching half dollars, with moderate success so far. My local bank (TD Bank) offers a free coin counting machine inside all of it's lobbies. This is my second trip and both times the counting machine has been off. Today I took $28 in halves and $6 in Presidential dollars. The machine shorted me $1.50. The first time I was shorted a $1.75 in a different location. Both times I let them know and they were very quick to give me the difference, but if I start going in multiple times, I don't want to look like I am doing something shady. Anyone run into this problems at TD Banks or your local banks? I suppose I can start rolling my own coins but this is so much faster and easier.
That happens at a local bank of mine (Not a national brand bank) But it usually only 50 cents since I do halves and i do it once a week so I see it as a "nice tip" because they are very nice about it. Are you sure you did not count off the silver coins you found?