I just found in some bank rolls several NIFC half dollars and a couple of proof halves with some greasy looking crud on them. How should I clean them?
General i don't like to tell people to clean coins because it is a big no no !! But in this case being they arent worth much you might as well give them a rinse !!
Vinegar has acid so steer clear of that. Soap will leave a residue on the coin which may show up weeks later in the form of spotting. The acetone shouldn't harm anything. Soak the coin in the acetone for a few minutes and observe the results. Longer soaks may be required. Just don't forget about the coin that's soaking. After you feel that the coin is ready to come out of the bath, rinse it with distilled water and allow it to dry on a soft surface.
Agreed the only thing being i don't know how acetone will affect the finish of the the proofs as i have never tried to clean one !! But it is worth a try i would be interested to see the results !!
I've never tried it on proofs either. I'll have to do a little experimenting with some hazy Ikes......
You should not be using enough acetone to require taking it outdoors. It only requires about half a shot glass full.