CARIA Mylasa . . . . or is it?

Discussion in 'Ancient Coins' started by Topcat7, Mar 8, 2022.

  1. Topcat7

    Topcat7 Still Learning

    I am attempting to attribute one of my (early) Greek coins, (12 mm., 1.86 gm.)
    and the closest I can get is CARIA Mylasa SNG Cop 421 . . . .
    Do you agree, or is there another possibility, perhaps. (I am concerned about the lack of 'S' squiggles between the prongs on the trident.)

    My Coin
    Magical_Snap_-_2022.03.08_15.42_-_060-removebg-preview.png

    from the pages of CNG.
    Magical Snap - 2022.03.08 16.02 - 062.png
     
    Edessa, DonnaML and Bing like this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. Curtis

    Curtis Well-Known Member

    I think so. I just happened to be looking up similar types in Historia Numorum Online last night when I saw a similar one (horse right) for sale at Forum. I don't know the research literature on which the attribution was ultimately based, but all these Horse / Trident-with-"S"-shapes coins seem to be attributed to Mylasa. (There's only one left one: N°: 321 ; but a bunch of right ones: N°: 319 ; N°: 320 ; N°: 734 ; N°: 1127 ; N°: 1128 ; N°: 1355 ).

    But attributions to Carian mints do seem to be particularly contested! We had a recent thread on Caria, Uncertain.

    A favorite little bronze coin (only 10mm, 1.16g) of mine from Mylasa (?) was interesting to me for this specimen's role in the controversy over its type's attribution:

    Caria Mylasa AE Ex Karl 246 Leu Web Auction 16.jpg
    PHOTO Credit: Leu WA 16 (Slg. Vogl)

    It's the example from the Erich Karl Collection who identified it as Caria, Mygissos. Translating from German, the catalog (Lanz 131, lot 246) stated:
    Mygissos, Myndos, Mylasa, Myous, Myrina... they actually left one out Nisyros!

    It was later in the P.R. Franke (Grün 64) and P. Vogl (Leu WA 16) collections, both of which sales identified it as Mylasa -- the usual ID.

    (When E. Karl originally bought it from
    Kölner Münzkabinett Auktion 49 [30-31 Oct 1989], Lot 27, it was identified as Caria, Myndos!)

    It is specimen number one in Historia Numorum Online Temp N. 1883.1 (no. 7 is the "plate coin")
     
    Last edited: Mar 8, 2022
    Edessa, Topcat7 and Bing like this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page