CAC Submission- Guess the Beans

Well I got accepted to CAC and this is going to be my first submission.

What, if any do you think will green or gold bean. I have 10 piggybacks in my order that I have photographed as well. 23 total coins.

1 1902 Indian MS64
2 1956-D Lincoln MS67 RB
3 1956-D Lincoln MS67 RB
4 1956-D Lincoln MS66 Star BN
5 1839-O Seated Half Dime AU53
6 1937 Buffalo Nickel MS64
7 1939 Jefferson Proof Rev of 38 PF66
8 1857 Seated Dime AU55
9 1891-O Seated Dime MS62
10 1894-O Barber Dime F12
11 1905-S Barber Dime AU58
12 1891 Seated Quarter MS62
13 1928 Standing Liberty Quarter VF25
14 1806/5 Bust Half VF20
15 1853 Seated Half VF35
16 1860-O Seated Half AU53
17 1943 Walking Liberty Half MS64
18 1948 Franklin Half MS64 FBL
19 1952 Franklin Half MS66
20 1952-S Franklin Half MS65
21 1955 Franklin Half Bugs Bunny MS66 FBL
22 1881-S Morgan Dollar MS64
23 1884-O Morgan Dollar MS64


















































Next 3 on next comment

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Green, gold, and a few without.

 

@BigTee44

Just a suggestion: edit your posts and number the submissions. It'll make it easier for members to judge.

 

done

 

Green on all

 

They've been pretty tight lately

1 No
2 No
3 No
4 Probably yes
5 No
6 Yes
7 No idea with proof nickels
8 Yes
9 No
10 Yes
11 No
12 No
13 No
14 No
15 Yes
16 Yes
17 Yes
18 Yes
19 No
20 Maybe
21 Don't think so, they seem to be harder on varieties
22 Yes
23 No

 

God I love that Standing Liberty... green.

 

The only one that really jumps out, is #18
The '48p Franklin i think it goes gold.

 

Toners are difficult for me to judge, but the '48 Franklin and the '37 Buffalo are gold candidates.

They all seem to be solidly graded. I'll love to find out what CAC thinks. Good luck!

 

I think 14 out of 23 green sticker:
2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22

 

I am probably overly tough, but the coin needs to be problem-free, solid for the grade, and have great eye appeal.

1 1902 Indian MS64 (yes)
2 1956-D Lincoln MS67 RB (No, not enough red)
3 1956-D Lincoln MS67 RB (No, not enough red)
4 1956-D Lincoln MS66 Star BN (Yes)
5 1839-O Seated Half Dime AU53 (No, not enough luster)
6 1937 Buffalo Nickel MS64 (Yes)
7 1939 Jefferson Proof Rev of 38 PF66 (Yes)
8 1857 Seated Dime AU55 (Yes)
9 1891-O Seated Dime MS62 (No, luster too subdued)
10 1894-O Barber Dime F12 (No, obverse scratches)
11 1905-S Barber Dime AU58 (No, toning too dark-hides luster)
12 1891 Seated Quarter MS62 (No, luster too subdued)
13 1928 Standing Liberty Quarter VF25 (Yes)
14 1806/5 Bust Half VF20 (Yes, might get gold)
15 1853 Seated Half VF35 (Yes)
16 1860-O Seated Half AU53 (No, obverse scratches)
17 1943 Walking Liberty Half MS64 (Yes)
18 1948 Franklin Half MS64 FBL (Yes, might get gold)
19 1952 Franklin Half MS66 (Yes)
20 1952-S Franklin Half MS65 (Yes)
21 1955 Franklin Half Bugs Bunny MS66 FBL (No, luster too subdued and can't see the FBL well)
22 1881-S Morgan Dollar MS64 (Yes)
23 1884-O Morgan Dollar MS64 (Maybe, luster is a bit weak for a 64, but everything else is right)

 

Very nice!

 

No one thinks the 1853 Half had a shot at a gold bean?

 

I did.

 

BTW, how did the 3rd 56d lincoln recieve a star grade but the 1st one did not??
PM me if its for sale !!

 

Results are in!!

Only took 4 days from when they signed for them! Mad props to CAC!


Any guesses before the results?

 

I stand beside my gold sticker prediction. All the coins look pretty solid. This will be a good lesson.

 

None got gold.

6 did not pass.

 

Wow, those are nice. Plenty should bean. Won't hazard a guess though. Giving me a headache trying.