This Saturday I bought a CH BU 1923s peace dollar and still had $15 dollars left in my budget. I would have normally not have spent the $15 but I saw the shop had a few barbers so I bought two of them a 1905 VF for $10 and a 1906 F for $5.25. The 1905 looks a little like a XF with full clear liberty (You can not see it well in this picture) And a almost perfect maple leaf (Which is hard for you to see well in this picture too). I would like other options regarding the grade.
Reverse definitely shows a cleaning IMO. I would expect as much for the obverse, though I can't see it as well.
Hard to tell from the images, if you could post some better pic's we would be able to assist better. The coin has been cleaned IMO as well.
Here's a good link for you, it should help a lot. PCGS Photograde Online http://www.pcgs.com/photograde/#/Barber10/Grades
