Are Coins Graded on a Curve?

I was just browsing eBay and found this beautiful 1798 half dime graded MS65. There is no way in my opinion that a coin minted in the modern day that looked to be in the same condition would grade MS65. That brings me to my question. Are older or more valuable coins graded on a different set of criteria than regular coins?

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1798-7-DRA...797617?hash=item288f980971:g:D6kAAOSw2oVeXK-8

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That was made in what might as well be an entirely different way than moderns. Curve probably isnt the right word, but yes ultra moderns/moderns/classics/really old classics/silver/clad/copper/gold/different mints etc are graded differently based off of what it is.

 

..ahahaha.....i wouldn't think so...but idk ....it stuck me funny...i pictured a group of coins taking a test....><

 

You’ll also often see grade bumps for rarity. I don’t agree with that, but that’s the fact

 

Yes. Older, rare coins do get a more generous treatment from the grading services. They will often get a pass on things that would bring a details grade or no grade on a more modern coin. For example, the Dexter 1804 dollar has a "D" stamped on it, yet it was straight-graded PR65. Stamp your initial on a ASE, send for grading, and see what happens.

Cal