I just bought a roll of 1943 pennies from eBay, and it had a perfectly red shining 1943 copper wheat penny!!! It does not stick to magnets or anything. I hear there are only 40? Am I rich? I do not know how to post pics sorry.
More likely subject to arrest if you try to sell it. There are more fakes out there than you can shake a stick at. Without a picture, we have no hope of saying what it is.
Check out this link so we can all have a chuckle looking at your fake, and at least some of us can point out the visible evidence. BTW the direct answer to your question is: Sure, if you were already rich before you opened the roll of cents.
If you have a partner and kids and can keep your family happy, you meet my prerequisites for being Rich!!!