A New way to guess the grade--Pick the 66

Thought I would throw a little twist in the guess the grade. Below are four Jefferson Nickels graded by NGC. Only one of the four is an MS66. Can you guess which one? For the real pros, try and guess the assigned grade of all four! Have Fun!






OK have at it.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

the only one I can imagine is the second coin

 

had 2 go with 4 because of the toning.

 

#2

 

Coin #4.

 

#2

 

Nobody wants to venture guesses for the grades of the other three, cluck cluck cluck.

 

1. MS65
2. MS67
3. MS65 FS
4. MS66

??? Just a guess.

 

Well, you got one right, but I can't tell which one of course.

 

65
68
66
65
Geeze I don't know if I'm right

 

64,65,64,66

 

You know the population of a 1939 Rev of 40 in MS68 is one. I wish it were mine, but alas, it is not.

 

If there is one it probably doesn't deserve a MS68 grade and was a resubmission.

 

I don't know much about Jeffersons at all... and I mean, at all!
Although, IMO that coin is the best of the group...

 

66
65
65
67

 

CLUCK CLUCK CLUCK! HAH

That is going to go a long way to your reputation!


We should sticky post that one!

Ruben

 

OK, and this is without looking at any responses or the polls, the first one would be my guess if it didn't have the nick in the collar and what appears to be a mark in the field by the eye, assuming that the second one's reverse is just a little washed out in the pic and not a really weak strike. So if it is kind of washed out I would say the second one would be the 66, the first a 65 and the last 2 64s.

 

66
67 (you got rooked)
67
67

 

I'll go out on a limb here, way out but say

I'll go out on a limb here, way out but say,
1st coin in 66
2nd coin is 67
Third 65
Forth is 65

 

"rim" I really did not look at yours before I post

"rim" I really did not look at yours before I posted but we do differ on the last 2.