I recently purchased this coin at my LCD and I've seen eBay auctions with this coin range anywhere from $50 to $100 and I was wondering what I should list it for because I am looking to sell it. Thanks for your help!
Check the auction results on CoinFacts. https://www.pcgs.com/coinfacts/coin/1970-s-1c-small-date-rd/2935
Yeah. $40 is a fair price based on those auctions. However, if you look on eBay, there is a ridiculous gap between selling prices. PCGS price guide also said $65
You are looking at 6 year old prices. The link I gave you will show several that were sold on ebay in 2018